BUILT IN THE USA. READY FOR YOUR PROJECT.
Metal-Clad vs. Metal-Enclosed Switchgear
Metal-clad and metal-enclosed describe related switchgear constructions, not interchangeable equipment packages.
DIRECT FROM THE MANUFACTURER / NEW EQUIPMENT

THE MANUFACTURER’S PERSPECTIVE — 02
Metal-clad and metal-enclosed describe related switchgear constructions, not interchangeable equipment packages. A metal-clad assembly belongs to the broader metal-enclosed family, but a metal enclosure alone does not make an assembly metal-clad. For engineers, contractors and owners comparing new equipment, the important questions are what separates the major components, which devices protect each circuit, and how the intended operating plan affects the purchase.
Start with the construction standard
In a typical North American medium-voltage specification, IEEE C37.20.2 addresses metal-clad switchgear with drawout electrically operated circuit breakers and grounded metal barriers separating major compartments. A specification should identify its applicable edition and required construction rather than relying on the appearance of a steel lineup. Confirm that the offered assembly meets the project’s defined requirements.
IEEE C37.20.3 addresses metal-enclosed interrupter switchgear, a different category that can include interrupter switches, fuses, circuit breakers and associated controls. A particular design may have fixed devices or added barriers and interlocks. Ask for the actual equipment arrangement: neither the presence of a breaker nor a metal housing alone establishes metal-clad construction.
What compartmentation changes
Metal-clad designs separate major parts such as the main bus, breaker and incoming or outgoing connections with grounded metal barriers. Drawout breaker construction and shutters at primary contacts are common distinguishing features. Request compartment and section drawings to see what is separated, where barriers are placed and which access provisions the proposed lineup actually includes.
A metal-enclosed interrupter design may organize its switches, fuses, buses and cables differently, depending on the product. The arrangement can reduce complexity, but a door does not necessarily provide the same separation between components. Compare the proposed compartment layout and access restrictions instead of assuming either complete separation or an absence of barriers.
Compare protective devices, not labels
A transformer feeder might be designed around a load-interrupter switch and power fuses, or around a breaker with protective relays. The switch and fuse perform different functions; their individual duties and the complete assembly must be suitable for the system. A relay-operated breaker provides different settings and control options, subject to the chosen devices.
The project engineer should evaluate available fault current, interrupting and withstand duties, transformer inrush, upstream and downstream protection, and coordination across the relevant fault range. Neither enclosure category automatically guarantees selective coordination or a higher fault rating. Require the quotation to identify the switching devices, protective functions and assembly ratings being proposed.
Plan access and continuity realistically
A drawout breaker can support a maintenance plan that isolates one device while other circuits remain in service, if the actual lineup and operating conditions permit it. That possibility is not a promise of uninterrupted operation. Shared buses, cable backfeeds, interlocks and the owner’s outage rules can change the work scope for a particular circuit.
Compartment barriers and shutters are not a substitute for a qualified-person electrical safety program. Metal-clad construction also does not automatically mean arc-resistant construction; specify any required internal-arc performance separately and verify its test designation and installation conditions. Qualified personnel must plan isolation, testing and work under applicable site procedures and manufacturer instructions.
Give the manufacturer a usable design basis
Supply a current one-line diagram showing sources, transformer connections, feeder destinations and any ties or alternate feeds. Include system voltage, equipment voltage class and insulation requirements, continuous-current needs, available fault duty and the protection study basis. Identify whether each feeder needs a breaker, a fused switch or another engineered arrangement.
Provide room or outdoor site constraints, cable entry direction, termination details, required working and maintenance access, and environmental conditions. Identify control power, instrument transformer needs, remote indications and communication interfaces. These inputs allow a direct manufacturer serving San Antonio, South Texas and nationwide to review feasibility without presuming a standard layout fits every project.
Make the procurement comparison complete
Metal-clad construction may add compartment hardware, drawout mechanisms and space, while a simpler metal-enclosed arrangement may be attractive where its protection and access provisions meet the design. Compare installed footprint, device maintenance, outage exposure and future expansion as well as the initial equipment quote. The lower-complexity option is not automatically the better total project fit.
Ask each bidder to document the applicable standard, deviations, compartment drawings, one-line, equipment ratings, interlocks and testing scope. Assign responsibility for field connections, protection settings, commissioning and acceptance records. Coordinate drawing reviews, component availability, fabrication and inspection with the project schedule; changes to the device or layout can affect both approvals and delivery timing.
LET'S BUILD SOMETHING RELIABLE — 03
Ready to talk
switchgear?
Tell us about the new equipment your project needs. Include as much or as little detail as you have today.
(951) 403-5738CALL TO DISCUSS YOUR PROJECT